Carolyn New York Swatches (More!)
Morning Vampies! Today I am going
to show you the other three Carolyn New York swatches I took. It is a
cold rainy grey day here and supposed to be the next couple days, so I thought these colors were fitting! I am
hoping to somehow take new pics of the Color Club cremes so I can show
you in decent lighting, but without my friend the sun around, it might
be difficult! The Carolyn New York polishes all had fabulous
consistency and application. All pics taken in sun
with no top coat.

Handball Courts
This is a really nice silvery dove grey shimmery polish. It went on pretty sheer so it needed three coats. I love, love, love grey polish and was really pleased with this. For a second I thought it might be close to OPI's Sheer Your Toys, but no. This is more grey and doesn't have the red flecks that OPI's does. It is very close to RBL's Concrete Jungle, but this has shimmer whereas that is a creme.

Hangin On The Stoop
This is a great concrete grey creme. I'm a HUGE fan of concrete grey so I needed this one for my collection. It's pretty pigmented so only needed two coats. You may be thinking, is this close to RBL's Concrete Jungle or China Glaze Recycle? Well it actually is almost an exact dupe for Recycle. Recycle might be a smidgen darker grey. It is definitely darker than Concrete Jungle though so if you like grey's get 'em both!

Subway Surfing
Ahhh a beautiful silver/grey, yet again! This took three coats because it was a little sheer. It's a nice light grey base with lots of very fine silver and maybe green/pink fine shimmer. Now I am going to compare it to all my other colors like it. Compared to Misa Wishing On A Star, it's not as dark and doesn't have the massive fine silver glitter. Compare to CND's Hyde In The Dark, it's the same grey base but doesn't have the silver glitter. Compare to OPI's Brand New Skates, it's a darker grey and doesn't have the gold shimmer that OPI's does. Compared to ManGlaze Fuggen Ugly, it isn't matte and doesn't have the rainbow effect of shimmer. Compared to Lippmann's Hit Me With Your Best Shot, it doesn't have the steel blue effect that Lippmann's does.Compared to butter LONDON's Chimney Sweep, it's not quite as dark and doesn't have the fine multi-colored shimmer. So all in all, I would say this isn't a dupe for anything I currently own!
You can find Carolyn New York polishes on their website here. They are all $5.50 each.
Vamp it up!


Handball Courts

Hangin On The Stoop

Subway Surfing
You can find Carolyn New York polishes on their website here. They are all $5.50 each.
Vamp it up!



All of those are fabulous! Hope you have a great Thanksgiving
Reply to this
Katee - Thanks! You have a great Turkey Day also!
Reply to this
The shimmery one looks awsome! I just put on Revlon Steel-etto so I kind of have the same color!
Reply to this
Thanks Sminkan. I love all grey's so much!
Reply to this
They revamped their site & now I cannot find Greenwich Ave to buy =\
Reply to this
Hi Anon - Oh no! I just tried to find it also with no luck. Sorry, they must have discontinued that one. I guess I got it just in time because I JUST got it like 2 weeks ago.
Reply to this
I was juuuust going to set up an order for an x-mas gift for myself, too. Glad you snagged yours, that'll teach me to wait
Reply to this
Hi Anon - Sorry you missed it, but maybe they'll bring it back someday!
Reply to this
Hi Anon - I don't have your email address but if you see this, they DO have Greenwich Ave on Carolyn's site! It's in the blue category!!
Reply to this
I know! I just saw it!
I was just coming by to post and let you know, lol. Thanks!
Now... must buy before it disappears again
Reply to this
I think I need all three of these! Grey polish is my weakness. Hangin On The Stoop is definitely my fave though!
Reply to this
Hi Jamie - Grey is a huge weakness for me as well!
Reply to this
kelly!
thank you for your swatches. thanks to you, i've just ordered the grey and dark blue polishes from CNY. they are so pretty! (i've just gotten into painting my nails visible colors).
keep up the good work.
Reply to this
Hi Britt,
You are welcome, hope you like!
Reply to this